All companies have an obligation to inform HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC), the UK's tax, payments and customs authority, about transactions in Employment Related Securities (ERS) that relate to their employees who are undertaking duties in the UK.

The definition of ERS is widely drafted and, although it does include typical share and share/stock option awards, many alternative arrangements may be covered by these rules, even beyond formal employee share schemes. The due date for filing the annual return for the 2019/2020 tax year is 6 July 2020. Events which take place during the year ended 5 April 2020 need to be detailed on the ERS return, which is then filed through the HMRC ERS online system.

Reportable events

Most security transactions involving UK employees and directors will be reportable. Therefore, as well as company incentive plans, the issue of shares or options to UK employees and directors (including future or past employees) needs to be reflected in an ERS return.

Even where an employee has paid market value for the securities or the securities have a modest value, the acquisition is almost certainly reportable. There are very few exceptions.

Apart from the issue of shares, other transactions in securities, or the right to acquire securities, are reportable. These events include and are not limited to:

  • The grant and exercise of options
  • The award of restricted stock units (RSUs)
  • Changes to the rights of securities
  • Acquisitions for more than market value e.g. under good leaver provisions if an employee receives the amount paid for shares, and their value has decreased
  • Share or option cancellations in exchange for consideration                                

Information required

A significant amount of information may be required depending on the type of transaction being reported.

This is not an exhaustive list but for an issue of securities or exercise of options the return must include details of:

  • The company issuing the shares, including its address
  • The names and National Insurance numbers of the employees
  • The number and type of securities awarded
  • Any restrictions that could affect the market value of the shares
  • Whether the employee has agreed to be taxed as though restrictions did not apply
  • The market value of each security and amounts which employees have paid for the shares
  • Whether payroll taxes have been applied (some share acquisitions, such as listed shares, are subject to PAYE and NICs)

The reporting of securities which are subject to PAYE and NICs and are 'net settled' is more onerous as HMRC have recently clarified their view on the reporting requirements.

If PAYE and NICs are payable in respect of ERS, and the employer pays these amounts on behalf of the employee, additional employee taxes may become payable if the employee does not reimburse the the employer within 90 days of the end of the tax year i.e. 4 July 2020.

Employees ceasing to be employed

If an employee leaves a company, the securities cease to be employment related securities seven years after leaving. Therefore, if an employee leaves holding options which are exercised within seven years of leaving, there may still be a requirement to report an exercise and account for payroll taxes, depending on the type of securities acquired.

Overseas companies

Companies parented overseas, or overseas companies with employees performing duties in the UK, will have reporting requirements for ERS in relation to those employees.

For employees who have moved between jurisdictions, there are more complex reporting requirements if transactions take place in respect of options, shares, and/or RSUs. This is also the case if the employee has moved from the UK or been seconded overseas.

No securities transactions during the tax year

If you have filed a return in the past, an annual 'nil return' is still required even if there are no reportable events during the tax year. If there will be no further reportable transactions during subsequent tax years, the scheme should be closed online so that the filing obligations are not ongoing.

Late returns

There is an automatic penalty of £100 per share scheme registered if the return is not filed on time. There is an additional £300 penalty charged on 6 October 2020 and again on 6 January 2021 if the return remains outstanding. Further penalties of up to £10 per day could be levied for returns which are outstanding after 6 March 2021.

Benefits from tax advantaged plans such as CSOPs may also be lost if these filings are not made on time. HMRC have not yet made clear whether they will relax the filing deadline or penalty rules in light of the COVID-19 crisis.

The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.