A Need for Prompt Action

All plans, programs, arrangements and individual agreements (plans) that are subject to Section 409A of the Code must be brought into technical documentary compliance with the requirements of Section 409A no later than December 31, 2007. In addition, transition rules adopted by the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) that allow for the amendment, restructuring or termination of plans that violate Section 409A without penalty also expire at the end of 2007.

Employers are encouraged to start now to identify their plans that are subject to Section 409A and to begin the process of bringing such plans into full compliance.

Merely adding savings clauses and other language expressing an intent to comply is not sufficient. Plans must be carefully reviewed to identify and amend or delete provisions that violate Section 409A and to incorporate all provisions required by Section 409A.

The task facing all employers is great. In some cases, formal board approval of the necessary changes will be required. Any delay merely increases the risk to your key executives.

Consequences of Not Acting

Failure to modify plans that are subject to Section 409A to bring them into full documentary compliance by this deadline will result in your executives being taxed in 2008 on previously deferred compensation amounts. In addition, your executives will be subject to a special, additional tax of 20 percent of the amount of the deferred compensation, and interest charges from January 2005 or the date of the original deferral, if later. This acceleration of tax liability and added taxes will result even if your executives do not directly benefit from the offending provisions in your existing plans.

Plans That Are Affected

The scope of Section 409A is very broad. It may apply to traditional elective deferred compensation plans, supplemental retirement benefit plans, change in control plans, severance plans and severance provisions in employment agreements, stock options and other equity awards. Any plan that provides for the payment of compensation in a year other than the year in which the services that give rise to the compensation were performed is potentially subject to Section 409A.

Some Key Areas of Concern

Following is a list of plans (or specific plan provisions) that are likely to require amendment to avoid violating Section 409A. This list is not intended to be comprehensive. All plans that involve the potential deferral of compensation should be evaluated in light of Section 409A.

  • Employment Agreements. Most, if not all, employment agreements providing severance benefits will need to be amended prior to the end of 2007 to incorporate certain Section 409A definitions and other provisions.
  • Equity Plans. Grant agreements involving below market options and Stock Appreciation Rights (SARS) will need to be amended to reset the strike price or to bring the terms of the grant into compliance with Section 409A. Non-public companies also will want to review whether to continue to use options in light of the rules governing determination of fair market value under Section 409A.
  • Change in Control Agreements. Plans that provide for payments triggered by a change in control with respect to the employer will need to be reviewed to insure that the change in control definition complies with Section 409A.
  • Supplemental Executive Retirement Plans (SERPS) Tied to Qualified Plans. Separate benefit election provisions will need to be incorporated into SERPS that "wrap around" qualified retirement plans.
  • Employer Discretion/Executive Elections. Any provision that gives the employer or an executive ongoing discretion in determining when deferred compensation is paid will need to be eliminated.
  • Foreign Plans. To the extent that U.S. citizens or resident aliens participate in plans outside the United States, such plans will need to be reviewed for Section 409A compliance.
  • Not-for-Profit (NFP) Employers. NFP Employers will need to consider the ramifications of Section 409A on existing deferred compensation arrangements. In a number of areas, compliance with both Section 409A and 457 will need to be coordinated.

The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.