A Note from the Editors

Energy & Sustainability Connections brings the latest developments in energy investing, legal insights, company activity, and industry events straight to your inbox. This month's features include:

  • Special Announcements: Mintz Levin's Sahir Surmeli was named a 2017 Mover and Shaker by The Social Shake-Up; Tom Burton was recognized in JD Supra's 2018 Readership Awards; and DBL Partners' Founder Ira Ehrenpreis received the NVCA 2018 Outstanding Service Award.
  • Leader in the News: VELCO, Vermont's transmission company, is creating a sustainable Vermont through its people, assets, relationships, and operating model.
  • Legal Feature: The world is changing! Mintz Levin's Sahir Surmeli explores how companies and B Corps are boosting ESG (economic, social, and governance) performance while securing lower cost capital.
  • Event Highlights: Get all the details on two of this year's biggest events in energy: Law Seminars International's 5th Annual Conference on Developing Electric Transmission in the Northeast (featuring ML Strategies' David O'Connor) and global energy event Horizon18, sponsored by Mintz Levin.
  • Washington Updates: Read the latest energy policy updates coming out of the Capitol, including a major research funding announcement at the Department of Energy.

For links to industry grant opportunities and stories from the business, policy, and research sectors of the energy and clean technology industry, please see our Energy Navigator.

You can subscribe to our Energy & Sustainability Matters blog here.

We would also like to remind our readers that you can always ask us anything at http://mintzedge.com/ask-anything/. We built the MintzEdge website as a resource for entrepreneurs and investors, and hope that all of you take advantage of the site and see how it can help you.

Special Announcements

Mintz Levin's Sahir Surmeli Named 2017 Social Media "Mover and Shaker" by The Social Shake-Up

We are proud to celebrate the recognition of our own Sahir Surmeli as one of this year's social media Movers and Shakers by The Social Shake-Up!

The Social Shake-Up Conference brings together hundreds of social media, digital, marketing, PR, tech, and communications professionals looking for a better way to integrate social media into their overall business strategies. Each year's conference recognizes several "Movers and Shakers:" thought leaders across industries who stand out for their effective, engaging use of social media for their brand or client.

Sahir is the only individual from a law firm to be recognized among this year's honorees. As Co-chair of the firm's Energy & Sustainability Practice, Sahir has been active on Twitter for several years and uses the platform to share interesting news, congratulate clients, share firm blogs and events, and more.

For the latest in energy law at Mintz and other tweet-spiration, be sure to follow Sahir at @EnergyCleanTech and our firm at @MintzLevin.

National Venture Capital Association Presents DBL Partners' Ira Ehrenpreis with the 2018 Outstanding Service Award

At its annual Leadership Gala on March 16, 2018, the National Venture Capital Association (NVCA) presented Ira Ehrenpreis, Founder and Managing Partner of DBL Partners, with the 2018 Outstanding Service Award.

Ira is an established leader in the venture capital community — and long-time friend of Mintz Levin's Energy & Sustainability Practice — who has demonstrated a commitment to energy and impact investment throughout his impressive career. He received the award in honor of his commitment of extraordinary time, resources, and dedication to NVCA efforts that in turn have benefitted the entire venture industry.

Congratulations to Ira for this much-deserved award! For more information about Ira's contributions to the venture community and about the 2018 NVCA Leadership Gala, see the NVCA's press release here.

Mintz Levin's Tom Burton Recognized by JD Supra in 2018 Reader's Choice Awards

Mintz Levin is proud to be recognized by JD Supra in its 2018 Reader's Choice awards. The annual program highlights the most widely read authors and articles throughout the past year. This year, five Mintz Levin attorneys were named JD Supra Top Authors in four different industries. Our Energy & Sustainability Co-chair Tom Burton was recognized as a Top Author in Energy, and his article "Blockchain Technology Could be Key to Smarter Energy Grid" was highlighted as among the most popular in 2017 on the subject of energy.

Congratulations to Tom and the E&S Practice for sharing and analyzing the most important issues facing the energy and sustainability sector. Be sure to follow Tom at @TomBurtonIII and subscribe to the Energy & Sustainability Matters blog here to stay updated!

Leader in the News

Vermont Electric Power Company (VELCO)

This month, we are excited to feature our client Vermont Transco LLC, and its manager the Vermont Electric Power Company (together, VELCO). VELCO is Vermont's transmission company that is creating a sustainable Vermont through its people, assets, relationships, and operating model. Last month, VELCO's strategic partnership with the energy analytics start-up, Utopus Insights, paid big dividends when Vestas, the world's largest wind turbine manufacturer, acquired the new company for $100 million before the venture was a year old. The acquisition breaks new ground in energy analytics and paves the way for renewable energy producers like Vestas to streamline and strategically expand the delivery of clean energy sources.

VELCO was formed in 1956 when Vermont's local utilities banded together to access St. Lawrence River hydropower. Today, VELCO is Vermont's statewide bulk transmission owner and operator with over $1 billion in assets, including 738 miles of transmission lines, 13,000 acres of rights-of-way, and a fiber optic communication network that monitors and controls the electric system and serves as a key link for Vermonters' high-speed data internet access. With a cooperative-like ownership model, VELCO acts as a convener of energy stakeholders, championing energy policy at the state and regional level that is aligned with Vermont values for the public good.

VELCO has been at the forefront of energy innovation throughout its history. In recent years, the company lent early support to IBM Research and its team at the Smarter Energy Research Institute, whose expertise in the fields of data science, software, utility operations, meteorology, and renewable and distributed energy would eventually form the core of Utopus Insights' workforce. During multiyear collaborative relationships with VELCO and other leading energy companies, the team developed digital weather forecasting and analytics systems to optimize renewable energy generation.

In 2014, IBM's team entered into a joint development agreement with VELCO. Over the past four years, this partnership has allowed the team to analyze all aspects of transmission and distribution utility operations, including solar and wind forecasting, congestion management, and renewables integration. The partnership has led to VELCO's deployment of the Vermont Weather Analytics Center, a tool that delivers advanced weather forecasts linked to customer demand data and to solar and wind generation models to help the utility manage energy demand, maximize asset value, and enhance grid reliability.

After helping the group realize many breakthroughs, VELCO and IBM announced the official creation of Utopus Insights, Inc., in February 2017. The new company provides digital solutions and analytics to help energy generators project and optimize renewable production. VELCO became a minority equity owner and strategic partner of the new company. The Vestas acquisition within a year of Utopus's founding is an indicator of the role Utopus could play in using weather prediction to optimize wind power dispatch.

We are proud to highlight VELCO's instrumental role in the creation and growth of Utopus Insights and VELCO's broader efforts at fostering innovations in energy management and renewable generation.

Legal Feature

Save the World, Reduce Your Cost of Capital: How Danone is Turning ESG Impact into Lower Borrowing Costs

This feature by Sahir Surmeli was originally published on the Mintz Levin Energy & Sustainability Matters blog.

The world is changing! Over the last several years, Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) criteria have been an emerging focus in the investing world. In a space primarily driven by equity investors, it can be harder for a company raising funds to correlate capital costs with ESG impact. Last month, multinational food-products giant Danone Group and its bank group, led by BNP Paribas, redefined the ESG landscape with a credit facility that is said to directly link borrowing rates to "verified positive impact on the world."

At a time when the social impact claims of global corporations are sometimes viewed with skepticism, Danone is flipping the ESG narrative around by keeping itself financially accountable to tangible incentives for sustainability. Twelve leading global banks, led by BNP Paribas, provide Danone's $2 billion syndicated credit facility on terms that provide for lower borrowing costs if Danone increases its impact by meeting certain ESG criteria. According to Danone's 2017 financial report, the third-party-verified metrics include increasing the percentage of consolidated sales of Danone covered by B Corp certifications and improving Danone's ESG scores under ratings evaluators like Sustainalytics and Vigeo Eiris. In other words, greater B Corp sales and higher ESG scores translate into cheaper capital – and a dozen major global credit providers are standing behind the innovative model. Even if the move results in only a small percentage of savings on loan rates for Danone, it could lead to several million dollars in annual savings for the company while providing a successful structure for more financings of this type.

For those of you not familiar with B Corp certification, it is a third-party certification of for-profit companies established by the nonprofit B Lab to meet rigorous standards of social and environmental performance, accountability, and transparency. If you want to learn more, check out the B Corp Declaration here.

Danone's reinforced commitment to ESG aligns squarely with what investment managers and a range of private funds have been calling for – a broader view of the mission of corporations. Even the New York lawyers are getting on board (I hope they catch up to me!): In his annual letter to corporate boards, Marty Lipton pushes boards to consider not only their stockholders but also their "expanded stakeholders," and explores how companies can build sustainability and social impact into their corporate governance strategy. Blackrock CEO Larry Fink recently made a more urgent call on CEOs to "start accounting for the societal impact of your companies, or risk disappointing the largest asset manager in the world." Investors across the board are increasingly placing their assets in companies that employ a model of long-term sustainability for both themselves and the communities and resources to which they are inextricably connected.

Now, the challenge is for CEOs, CFOs and Boards of Directors to determine how their company can keep up with the ESG wave and the new standards it places on financial performance. Replicating the B Corp-centered track Danone and its banks established is a good place to start. While the Danone approach is revolutionary, it is not surprising, considering the household name conglomerate was the first Fortune 500 Company to announce its goal of becoming a Certified Benefit Corporation in 2017. And it's well on track to reaching that goal, building a strong partnership with B Lab while guiding ten of its subsidiaries towards the successful completion of the B Impact Assessment. If companies want to remain competitive with both investors and financial partners moving forward, it's clear that the benefit corporation mentality is no longer simply beneficial – it's vital.

Event Highlights

Electric Transmission in the Northeast

Our own David O'Connor of ML Strategies will speak on a panel entitled "Coordinated Procurement: Outcomes and Lessons from Recent Solicitations and Responses" at Law Seminars International's 5th Annual Conference on Developing Electric Transmission in the Northeast. Taking place April 5-6 in Boston and via webcast, this conference covers legal, business, and regulatory developments in the electric generation and transmission industry. For more information and to register, click here.


Mintz Levin is excited to announce our sponsorship of Horizon18, a new global event for the clean energy economy that is taking place October 10-11, 2018 in Boston. This event will bring together clean economy customers, vendors, investors, and innovators and include keynotes, interactive workshops, a showcase of clean energy solutions and initiatives, and a unique business matchmaking platform to foster the exploration of new market opportunities and business partnerships for clean energy solutions and innovations.

We will continue to bring you additional news about Horizon18 through our newsletter and blog. In the meantime, please click here to visit the event website for more information.

Washington Updates


With just hours left to avoid another government shutdown, on March 22 Congress approved an omnibus spending bill for the remainder of the current fiscal year which ends on September 30. Following the passage of the omnibus, the Department of Energy released a statement highlighting spending that had been set aside for energy issues. The spending package includes $6.3 billion for Science research programs; $2.3 billion for Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy (EERE); $1.2 billion for Nuclear Energy; $727 million for Fossil Energy; $351 million for the Advanced Research Projects Agency-Energy (ARPA-E); and $7.1 billion for Environmental Management (EM). Funding for the DOE in the spending bill totals $34.5 billion. Secretary Perry stated that the spending bill would provide certainty for the department and that he is pleased to see that the president signed on to a bill that "funds our missions and will allow us to do great work for American energy." The DOE budget also provides funding for critical priorities; this includes over $500 million to advance exascale computing and over $100 million for cybersecurity to protect the electric grid and energy infrastructure. A summary of the Energy and Water Development portion of the omnibus can be found here.

On March 8 the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee held a business meeting to approve 24 energy, lands, and territories bills. The bipartisan measures include bills to address Northern Mariana islands workforce needs; expedite the approval of small-scale LNG exports; boost research efforts at the Department of Energy; and facilitate federal land exchanges, studies, and historic sites.

On March 14 the House Energy and Commerce Committee held a hearing on "DOE Modernization: Legislation Addressing Cybersecurity and Emergency Response" with testimony from Mark Menezes, Under Secretary, U.S. Department of Energy; Scott Aaronson, Vice President, Security and Preparedness, Edison Electric Institute; Mark Engels, Senior Enterprise Security Advisor, Dominion Energy; Kyle Pitsor, Vice President, Government Relations, National Electrical Manufacturers Association; Zachary Tudor, Associate Laboratory Director for National and Homeland Security, Idaho National Laboratory; and Tristan Vance, Director, Chief Energy Officer, Indiana Office of Energy Development.

Department of Energy

The Department of Energy (DOE) has announced up to $32.5 million in federal funding for cost-shared research and development to advance solid oxide fuel cell technologies, which will enable efficient, cost-effective electricity generation from domestic coal and natural gas resources with minimal use of water and near-zero atmospheric emissions of carbon dioxide and pollutants.

DOE's Oak Ridge National Laboratory and National Energy Technology Laboratory have signed a Memorandum of Understanding for innovative coal research. The two laboratories will conduct research on the reduction of water consumption in energy production; development and testing of materials for use in extreme environments with an emphasis on materials for power generation and the conversion, use, storage, and transmission of energy; development of advanced electrical grids, microgrids, and cybersecurity technologies for energy infrastructure; innovation of advanced manufacturing technology for energy production, especially fossil-energy technologies; and execution of workforce and economic development initiatives in the Appalachian region.

The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.