In the media
PS information popular with the public
Victorian Information Commissioner, Sven Bluemmel joined
the Acting Commonwealth Ombudsman and Commissioners from NSW,
Queensland and Western Australia to release the findings of their
Information Access Study 2021 and sign a joint statement (07
October 2021).
More...
COVID-19 tracing data must be protected by law
nationally
Federal legislation is urgently needed to ensure COVID-19
tracing data is used only for health purposes in every state and
territory, says the Australian Lawyers Alliance as the Greens plan
to introduce a bill to Parliament that will ban law enforcement
agencies from accessing this data (07 October 2021).
More...
Big Tech warns of Australian online safety reforms'
cybersecurity risks
The federal government's online safety reforms will
lead to "widespread cybersecurity risks" comparable to
the infamous Ashley Maddison data leak and may see "the work
of one arm of government undoing the work of another",
according to a number of leading global tech firms (07 October
2021).
More...
Lifting the veil of secrecy: Court rules parts of
Collaery case to be heard in public
The ACT Court of Appeal has ruled that parts of the
ongoing prosecution of Bernard Collaery should be open to the
public (06 October 2021).
More...
IBAC to hold public hearings into allegations of serious
corrupt conduct involving Victorian Members of Parliament
Public hearings into allegations of serious corrupt
conduct involving Victorian public officers, including Members of
Parliament, will commence on 11 October. The hearings are part of
Operation Watts, which is looking into a range of matters including
allegations of 'branch stacking (30 September 2021).
More...
Audit launched into Services Australia's reliance on
contractors
The national audit office has turned its attention to the
prevalence of contractors at Services Australia, following concerns
the agency has a "serious problem" with tech capability
due to its over-reliance on outsourced work. The ANAO has also
launched an audit into the Department of Defence's use of
contractors with the same terms of reference (30 September 2021).
More...
ACMA releases 2021–22 research program
The ACMA has released its 2021–22 research program,
which will examine a range of topics across the Australian media
and communications landscape, including unsolicited communications
– phone calls, SMS and email and an examination into the use
of affiliate marketing in online gambling (28 September 2021).
More...
Victoria launches home quarantine trial using facial
recognition tech
The Victorian government has launched a trial of home
quarantine for returning residents using facial recognition and
geolocation technology, the latest in a number of states to embark
on similar pilots (28 September 2021).
More...
Freedom of Information changes go too far
On the International Day for Universal Access to
Information, the Law Council of Australia has expressed concern the
COAG Legislation Amendment Bill 2021 extends Freedom of Information
exemptions too broadly and without adequate justification (28
September 2021).
More...
International Access to Information Day 2021
The Office of the Australian Information Commissioner is
calling for an open-by-design approach to managing government-held
information as it marks International Access to Information Day on
28 September (27 September 2021).
More...
OAIC publishes annual report on digital health
The independent privacy regulator for the My Health Record
system and Healthcare Identifiers Service has detailed its
compliance and monitoring activity in its 2020–21 digital
health annual report. The annual report highlights the OAIC's
work to ensure privacy measures for Australia's digital health
systems are upheld (21 October 2021).
More...
Victoria's privacy commission orders release of
secret COVID lockdown briefings
The health department is ordered to release the details of
confidential lockdown briefings in a ruling from the Office of the
Victorian Information Commissioner (20 October 2021).
More...
Australians on board with vaccine passport
Senator Reynolds said Services Australia's Visible
Digital Seal technology within the new document was world-leading,
as secure as an Australian passport and was authenticated in the
same way. The Minister said the international certificate met the
new global standard specified by the International Civil Aviation
Organization and conformed with World Health Organization guidance
(18 October 2021).
More...
New Office to investigate police in Victoria
The Office of the Special Investigator was formally
established this week with powers to examine the potential criminal
conduct and disciplinary matters raised by the Royal Commission
into the Management of Police Informants(14 October 2021).
More...
Gambling watchdog probe urges ban on high-roller
junkets, but critics say 'they've missed the
point'
An independent probe into Victoria's under-fire
gambling watchdog could not substantiate allegations that Crown
exercised undue influence on inspectors, but recommends parliament
ban junkets for overseas high rollers (13 October 2021).
More...
In practice and courts
Review of PBR Act and IPEA Act
The statutory review will consider how the current
legislative framework provides appropriate levels of accountability
and transparency to the use of taxpayers' money. The Review
will report by 31 December 2021.
More...
Law Council Update
The Law Council produces a fortnightly newsletter which
highlights the Law Council's important activities and advocacy,
along with any relevant media and events stakeholders would be
interested in.
1
October 2021
15 October 2021
AAT Bulletin
The AAT Bulletin is a weekly publication containing a list
of recent AAT decisions and information relating to appeals against
AAT decisions
Issue No. 20/2021, 4 October 2021
Issue No. 21/2021, 18 October 2021
Draft legislation for Australian Government Digital Identity System
The proposed legislation will enshrine in law, privacy and consumer safeguards for greater trust in the System as it expands. This includes more services and sectors, accelerating an economy-wide rollout. Submissions are open until 27 October 2021. Visit digitalidentity.gov.au/have-your-say for more information.
AAT: In-person hearings in our Canberra, Melbourne and
Sydney registries
Until further notice, in-person hearings in our Canberra,
Melbourne and Sydney registries will only proceed when all parties,
representatives and other participants are willing to show evidence
that they have been fully vaccinated (18 October 2021).
More...
Consultation on review of the Workplace Gender Equality
Act 2012
The Workplace Gender Equality Agency has invited feedback
on a review of the law covering workplace gender equality in
Australia, on anissued a consultation paper which covers the
current legislation, enshrined in the Workplace Gender Equality Act
2012, as well as gender indicators and continuing employer
reporting obligations. Submissions close on 24 November and further
information can be accessed on the PM&C website at this
PS News link.
Victoria
Changes to Supreme Court of Victoria file searches and
affidavits
The Supreme Court of Victoria has new rules relating to
court file searches and affidavits, which will come into effect on
1 October 2021, evidentiary documents filed in a proceeding,
including affidavits, exhibits to affidavits, witness statements,
expert reports, written submissions, outlines of argument and
chronologies, may not be inspected by any non-party until the
document has been read or relied on in open court or for an
application determined without a hearing.
Practice Note SC Gen 20 Inspection of Civil Court Files by
Non-Partiesand
Notice to the Profession (Changes to File Inspections and
Affidavits)have been published on the Court's website,
providing further details of the changes and how they apply in the
Common Law Division and Commercial Court. Further information on
these changes can be found in the
Supreme Court news story.
Supreme Court of Australia Library
JudgmentsBulletin
The Law Library of Victoria produces a fortnightly
bulletin that summarises the latest legislation and cases for the
Victorian jurisdiction, as well as High Court of Australia cases.
Download the most recent Library Bulletin:
Law Library Bulletin No 19 (8 October 2021)
Law Library Bulletin No 20 (fortnight ending 22 October
2021)
Victoria Legal Aid: Shaping a fairer, more effective
criminal justice system
We've shared our key focusses for reform with the inquiry
into Victoria's criminal justice system. The focus of our
submission is on four key areas that reflect a person's journey
into and through the criminal justice system (22 October 2021).
More...
Consultations
Inquiry into Whether Victoria Should Participate in a
National Electoral Roll Platform – have your say
TheElectoral Matters Committee is accepting submissions to
its Inquiry into whether Victoria should participate in a national
electoral roll program. Submissions close on22October 2021. More...
Inquiry into Commonwealth support for Victoria –
have your say
TheLegislative Assembly Economy and Infrastructure
Committeeis accepting submissions to its Inquiry into Commonwealth
support for Victoria. Submissions close on29 October 2021. More...
Legal Aid Brief eNewsletter
Legal Aid Brief is Victoria Legal Aid's ?fortnightly
eNewsletter that keeps you up to date with legal aid matters.
More...
Commonwealth and Victorian Courts' COVID updates
– 22 October 2021
For up-to-date information about the Courts'
responses, please visit their websites:
Supreme Court of Victoria – see
here. County Court of Victoria – see
here. Magistrates' Court of Victoria – see
here.
This week saw the establishment of a referral scheme for pro bono
assistance to help unrepresented litigants involved in family law
proceedings. It is a joint initiative of the Federal Circuit and
Family Court of Australia and the Victorian Bar. More information
is available on the Courts' website
here (15 October 2021).
Published – articles, papers, reports
Annual Report 2020–21
VAGO: 5 October 2021
This report covers the activities of VAGO for the period 1 July
2020 to 30 June 2021. It is prepared in accordance with the Audit
Act 1994 and the Financial Management Act 1994, and complies with
the requirements of relevant Australian Accounting Standards and
Interpretations, Standing Directions and Financial Reporting
Directions. More...
2020–21 digital health annual report
Australian Information Commissioner: Released 21 October
2021
The OAIC received and finalised seven complaints in relation to the
My Health Records system, and received and finalised one complaint
relating to the Healthcare Identifier Service. The OAIC was
notified of two data breaches involving the My Health Record
system.
More....
Cases
Kassam v Hazzard;
Henry v Hazzard [2021] NSWSC
1320
PUBLIC HEALTH ACT – COVID-19 – public health
orders made under s 7(2) of the Public Health Act – orders
designate certain areas of concern and restrict movement out of the
home and out of the area –authorised workers able to leave
area of concern but only if vaccinated – orders allow
residents of area of concern to enter and remain on construction
sites but only if vaccinated. ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – proof of
basis upon which Minister for Health acted – Minister did not
give evidence – part of documents relied on subject of public
interest immunity claim as documents produced to sub-committee of
cabinet - whether Jones v Dunkel inference or Blatch v
Archer reasoning available against Minister and State –
position of Ministers with competing responsibilities – no
adverse inference available – Blatch v Archer
reasoning not available ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – grounds of
challenge – relevant considerations – how derived and
how framed – procedural fairness – no obligation to
afford procedural fairness in making public health orders affecting
a vast number of persons – not proven that making of orders
was not a genuine exercise of the Minister's power –
unreasonableness – adducing of evidence to undermine factual
basis for making of orders – decision to make orders informed
by policy considerations – whether differential treatment of
unvaccinated persons consistent with objects of Public Health Act
– all grounds of review rejected. CONSITUTIONAL LAW –
whether orders and section 7 of the Public Health Act rendered
invalid by s 51(xxiiiA) of the Constitution – orders do not
create any form of civil conscription in the provision of medical
and dental services – s 51(xxiiiA) does not limit legislative
power of the States – no joint scheme with Commonwealth to
effect civil conscription – neither orders or Public Health
Act dependent for its operation on any joint scheme with
Commonwealth – argument untenable – no inconsistency
between orders, Public Health Act and Australian Immunisation
Register Act 2015.
Legislation
Victoria
Victorian legislation can be accessed here.
This publication does not deal with every important topic or change in law and is not intended to be relied upon as a substitute for legal or other advice that may be relevant to the reader's specific circumstances. If you have found this publication of interest and would like to know more or wish to obtain legal advice relevant to your circumstances please contact one of the named individuals listed.